top of page
carnivory_phylogeny.png

BACKGROUND

Diet is a powerful selective force acting during evolution, with consequences for a species’ physiology, morphology, behavior, persistence time, and diversification rate. Earlier work investigated the effect of diet on macroevolutionary dynamics in mammals and found that omnivores have the lowest diversification rates, while herbivores have the highest. Similar patterns have been observed in birds, insects, and crustaceans.

 

However, other studies have shown that ecological factors, like diet, have different impacts on diversification at different taxonomic levels.

Additionally, categorizing species into qualitative classes based on diet – especially using a coarse classification system of herbivore, carnivore, and omnivore – leads to a loss of information. Species with highly varied diets are clustered into potentially uninformative groupings. An additional problem with using a categorical variable is the need to choose diet categories and set boundaries between them, resulting in a lack of standardization of diet categorization in the literature. A quantitative, continuous classification of diet based on food consumption percentages may be preferred, as downstream results are less impacted by arbitrary cutoffs decided upon earlier in the study.

OUR STUDY

In our study, we had three main objectives. First, we traced the evolutionary history of diet in Mammalia by identifying shifts in degrees of carnivory and dietary specialization. Second, we assessed the relative importance of carnivory and dietary specialization on speciation rates in different mammalian clades. Third, we identify significant relationships between diet and speciation rates across various taxonomic levels.

Our observations reveal that degree of carnivory significantly impacts speciation rates in Mammalia, while dietary specialization does not. At lower phylogenetic levels, degree of carnivory significantly affected speciation in ungulates, carnivorans, bats, eulipotyphlans, and marsupials, while dietary specialization only had a significant impact in carnivorans. Across Mammalia, we found that omnivores exhibit the lowest speciation rates.

We argue that treating variables such as diet as continuous instead of categorical reduces information loss and avoids the problem of contrasting macroevolutionary signals caused by differential discretization of biologically continuous traits.

THE EVOLUTION OF CARNIVORY AND DIETARY SPECIALIZATION ACROSS MAMMALIA

MD Pollard, and EE Puckett. Evolution of degrees of carnivory and dietary specialization across Mammalia and their effects on speciation. https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.09.15.460515

ASSOCIATED PREPRINTS

bottom of page